Metal vs. Tile Roofs: Which is the Best Option for Your Home?
If you’re looking to replace your old, worn-out roof, you may be debating between metal and tile roofs. Both have their advantages and disadvantages when it comes to durability, longevity, weather resistance, aesthetics, and cost.
This article will examine the key differences between metal and tile to help you determine which is the best roofing material for your home.
The Problem: Your Old Roof Needs Replacing
Has your roof started leaking? Are shingles blowing off in windstorms? Do you see sunlight peeking through in places? If so, it’s probably time to replace it. While a new one is a significant investment, it’s necessary. An old, failing roof can lead to much more costly issues like rot, mold, and structural damage. Don’t wait until it’s an emergency, be proactive and start shopping for a new one now.
The Solution: Metal or Tile?
When choosing a new roof, two popular options are metal and concrete tile. Both offer benefits over traditional asphalt shingles. Let’s look at the pros and cons of each material:
Metal Roofs
Pros
- Extremely durable and long-lasting, typically 50+ years
- Require little care
- Resistant to fire, rot, mold, and insects
- Energy efficient
- Reflective properties lower cooling costs
- Lightweight yet very strong
- Come in a wide variety of styles and colors
Cons
- Higher upfront cost than asphalt shingles
- Can be noisy during rain or hailstorms
- Metal conducts heat easily, may not be suitable for hot climates
Tile Roofs
Pros
- Extremely durable, lasting 50-100 years
- Fire resistant and wind/hail proof
- Aesthetically pleasing, come in many designs/styles
- Add value by increasing your home’s curb appeal
- Cooler than other roofing product types in summer
Cons
- Heavier than other roofs, requiring reinforced framing
- Higher upfront cost
- Can be prone to breaking and cracking
- Require more regular maintenance than metal roofing
Key Factors to Consider
When deciding between metal and tiled roof, keep these key factors in mind:
| Factor | Metal | Tile |
|---|---|---|
| Longevity | Extremely durable, 50+ years | Very durable, 50-100 years |
| Weather resilience | Excellent against all weather | Excellent against all weather |
| Fire proof | Highly fire resistant | Fire resistant |
| Maintenance | Low maintenance | Moderate maintenance |
| Aesthetics | Many styles and colors | Many styles, highly decorative |
| Energy efficiency | Highly efficient | Moderately efficient |
| Cost | Around $6-12 per square foot installed. | Around $10-25 per square foot installed. |
As you can see, both have excellent sturdiness and weather tolerance. Key differences come down to servicing requirements, energy efficiency, aesthetics, and cost. Metal roofs require less maintenance while tile provides a more decorative look. Roof tiles are generally more expensive to purchase and install than metal.
Pro Tip
Before choosing a new tile covered roof, be sure to consider potential repair and storm damage costs in your area. The installation cost may be higher than metal, and tiles can crack and break over time. In extreme temperature conditions, tiles can be more prone to damage than metal roofing.
The Bottom Line
When it’s time to replace your roof, you can’t go wrong with either metal or tile. Both are smart investments that will protect your house for decades to come.
For the ultimate in endurance and resource efficiency with minimal upkeep, a metal roof is your best bet. If you want an eye-catching roof with a classic architectural style, tile is a great option despite the higher management. Consult with professional roofers to determine which material will work best on your home and budget.
With proper installation and care, a new metal or tile roofing will provide your home and family with lasting protection and peace of mind. Don’t wait until it’s too late, schedule your roof replacement consultation today!
